Behold, I tell you
a mystery; we shall not all sleep, but we shall all be changed, in a moment, in
the twinkling of an eye, at the last trumpet; for the trumpet will sound, and
the dead will be raised imperishable, and we shall be changed.
- 1
Corinthians 15:51- 52
It is not unusual
for some posttribulationists to think that they have fired a silver bullet
which they believe destroys the possibility of the pretribulational rapture
teaching. That shot is usually
thought to be in the form of the argument relating to " the last trumpet" as
found in 1 Corinthians 15:52. Even
though some think they have found a slick and simple solution to the timing of
the rapture, they fail to realize that the New Testament teaching concerning
this issue is more sophisticated than that.
Scripture Or A Survival Guide?
I recall years
ago meeting and talking with the late Jim McKeever at a Christian Book Sellers
convention in the early 90s. He
made the " last trumpet" argument to me at that time. Later I read his book entitled Christian Will Go Through
The Tribulation.[1] Judging from the title, I thought it
would be a biblical treatise providing through reasoning to support the book' s
title. It was any thing but that! He basically presented a single
argument, (the last trumpet argument), in just a few pages and drew the
following conclusion:
If a Christian will put out of his
mind all of his preconceived ideas about a Rapture occurring at the beginning
of the Tribulation, and will look objectively at what the Scriptures have to
say, I believe he will conclude that the Rapture will occur at the end of the Tribulation. 1 Corinthians 15 tells us that we will be changed in the
twinkling of an eye, and that the dead will be raised at the " last
trumpet." In Revelation, at the LAST trumpet we see the beginning of Christ' s reign
and the FIRST
resurrection. Nothing could be
simpler. There are no
complications, if you accept the fact that the Rapture occurs at the end of the
Tribulation.[2]
First of all, I
arrived at my pretribulational beliefs through the study of the Bible, thus, I
am not going just put them out of my mind when I am challenged to examine the
beliefs of others. I doubt the
Bereans put their understanding of the Bible out of their minds when " they received the word with great eagerness, examining the
Scriptures daily, to see whether these things were so" (Acts 17:11). So we are to do just the opposite of
what McKeever and others like him when they suggest that we approach any issue
with an open mind. I do not want
to be open-minded when examining issues, I want to be biblically-minded.
Second,
we should not use a reductionist approach to Scripture, as McKeever suggests,
when an issue involves a degree of sophistication. Such an approach is often used by opponents of the Trinity
and the hypostatic union of Christ.
If one applies a reductionist approach to Scripture in relation to the
Trinity and the hypostatic union, it would only lead to heretical conclusions.
Third,
McKeever frontloads his own approach to the matter by taking the phrase " last
trumpet" and equating it with the seventh trumpet in Revelation
(11:15- 19). (This is an erroneous
assumption that I will deal with later.)
McKeever says, " A significant thing is that verse 52 tells us WHEN all of this will occur, and this " at
the LAST trumpet.
. . . It would then seem
reasonable to turn to the book of Revelation to find out something about this
' last' trumpet." [3]
Other than a
fraction of this single chapter, which very weakly argues for his " last
trumpet" view, the rest of the book (17 chapters and about 350 pages) is a
survival guide on how to make it alive through the tribulation. It just so happens that McKeever was a
key player in the survivalist movement and he provides great detail, something
lacking concerning His biblical arguments for posttribulationism, for how to
prepare to survive the tribulation.
I have often thought that if one really believes in posttribulationism,
then, logically it should lead to survival preparation that would aid the
church in going through the tribulation.
I am sure that there are a few posttribulationists who have made some
preparation, but such preparation appears to be generally lacking with those
who hold this view.
Biblical Trumpets
Paul does teach
in 1 Corinthians 15:52 that the rapture will take place at the last
trumpet. Do posttribulationist
like McKeever have a point or is there a better explanation that takes into
account the whole counsel of God on this matter? How does Paul' s last trumpet statement harmonize with
pretribulationism?
Throughout the
Bible there are a number of trumpets being blown. For example in Numbers 10 there are trumpets being used in
order to give commands to the people of Israel. For example, a trumpet is used to assemble the people for
their journey and another trumpet that signals the start of their journey. There were trumpet sounds that would
tell the people to stop and another sound telling them to assemble. Depending upon whether the people were
moving are getting ready to move, the last trumpet would signal them to move or
if moving, a second last trumpet sound would tell them when to stop. So even in this context, for example,
there are multiple " last trumpets."
Trumpets in Revelation
Some
midtribulationist and posttribulationists attempt to equate the " last trumpet"
in 1 Corinthians 15:52 with the seventh trumpet in Revelation 11:15- 18. Revelation 11:15, does not say
specifically " last trumpet."
Instead, the Revelation passage says " the seventh angel sounded." The seventh trumpet is the seventh in a
series of judgments. The seventh
trumpet is the last in a series of trumpet judgments but it is not the last
judgment in the series, seven more judgments (bowls) follow.
The " last
trumpet" of 1 Corinthians 15:52 is singular, referring to one judgment, not a
sequence of seven. Ellicott notes,
" There are no sufficient grounds for supposing that there is here any reference
to the seventh Apocalyptic trumpet (Rev. xi. 15), or to the seventh and last
trumpet." [4] Henry Thiessen agrees:
If he had thought of this trumpet
as one of seven, he would undoubtedly have said something like the
following: " For when the trumpets
will be sounded and the time comes for the last one to sound, the dead in
Christ shall be raised." At any
rate, there is no ground for identifying the " trump" in 1 Cor. 15:52 with the
seventh trumpet in Rev. 11:15.
Those in the Revelation introduce fearful judgments upon the world and
mankind; this one calls the dead in Christ out of their graves and summons both
the ones raised and the believers still living into the Lord' s presence.[5]
If the seventh
trumpet in Revelation and the last trumpet in 1 Corinthians 15:52 are supposed
to be a reference to the same thing, then why are there many more months of
judgment that follow the supposed last trumpet in Revelation 11. The view that equates the last trumpet
in 1 Corinthians 15:52 with the seventh trumpet of Revelation does not
harmonize in any way.
1 Corinthians 15:52
The context of 1
Corinthians 15:52 is very different than the context of Revelation 11:15. 1 Corinthians 15:52 better harmonizes
with 1 Thessalonians 4:16, which says, " For the Lord Himself will descend from
heaven with a shout, with the voice of the archangel, and with the trumpet of
God; and the dead in Christ shall rise first." Both passages speak of the rapture and judgment is absent
from both. The trumpet in both are
the last or final command that the Lord gives to the church, resulting in the
translation of all Believers. Dr.
J. Dwight Pentecost cites the following reasons as to why the " last trumpet" in
1 Corinthians 15:52 is different from any of the trumpet judgments in
Revelation.
There seem to be a number of
observations which make it impossible for one to identify these two
trumps. (1) The trumpet of 1
Corinthians 15:52, . . . sounds before the wrath of God descends, while, . . .
the chronology or Revelation indicates that the trumpet in Revelation 11:15
sounds at the end of the time of wrath. . . . (2) The trumpet that summons the church is called the trump
of God, while the seventh trump
is an angel' s trumpet. . . . (3)
The trumpet for the church is singular.
No trumpets have preceded it so that it can not be said to be the last
of a series. The trumpet that
closes the tribulation period is clearly the last of a series of seven. (4) In 1 Thessalonians 4 the voice
associated with the sounding of the trumpet summons the dead and the living and
consequently is heard before the resurrection. In the Revelation, while a resurrection is mentioned
(11:12), the trumpet does not sound until after the resurrection, showing us
that two different events must be in view. (5) The trumpet in 1 Thessalonians issues in blessing, in
life, in glory, while the trumpet in Revelation issues in judgment upon the
enemies of God. (6) In the
Thessalonian passage the trumpet sounds " in a moment, in the twinkling of an
eye." In Revelation 10:7 the
indication is that the seventh trumpet shall sound over a continued period of
time, probably for the duration of the judgments that fall under it, for John
speaks of the angel that shall " begin to sound." . . . (7) The trumpet in 1 Thessalonians is
distinctly for the church. Since
God is dealing with Israel in particular, and Gentiles in general, in the
tribulation, this seventh trumpet, which falls in the period of the
tribulation, could not have reference to the church without losing the
distinctions between the church and Israel. (8) The passage in Revelation depicts a great earthquake in
which thousands are slain, and the believing remnant that worships God is
stricken with fear. In the
Thessalonian passage there is no earth quake mentioned. . . . (9) While the church will be rewarded
at the time of the rapture, yet the reward given to " thy servants the prophets,
and to the saints" can not be that event.
The rewarding mentioned in Revelation 11:18 is seen to take place on the
earth after the second advent of Christ, following the judgment on His
enemies. Since the church is
rewarded in the air, following the rapture, these must be two distinct events.[6]
Conclusion
The last trumpet
in 1 Corinthians 15:52 is the final command that Christ provides for His church
when He sends the signal to gather us together for the meeting in the sky that
we know as the rapture. The contexts
of 1 Corinthians 15:52 and that of Revelation 11 are totally different from one
another. About the only similarity
between the two is that the word " trumpet" is used in both. (Actually the word " trumpet" is not
even used in Revelation 11:15- 19.
The text actually says, " the seventh angel sounded" (11:15), clearly
implying that a trumpet is sounded as noted in Revelation 8:2). The respective contexts are totally
different. In 1 Corinthians 15:52,
there is the context of things related to the church age, while Revelation 11
speaks of judgment during the tribulation. No such silver bullet argument exists for posttribulationism
since I believe that it is clear that the New Testament does not teach such a
view. Maranatha!
